Fender American Vintage II Telecaster
Aftermarket Price History
Used-market sales only. Brand New listings excluded.
American Vintage II Telecasters are Fender's current year-specific U.S. reissues, built to go harder on historical accuracy than the broader American Original line did. Era-correct pickups, lacquer finishes, period neck shapes and the right bridge and saddle formulas are what define the segment and justify the price gap over player-focused production Teles. On the used market, originality is everything, and the audience cares more about correctness and completeness than about flashy finish rarity. It is the right page for buyers who want a new Tele that behaves as much like a specific old Tele as Fender can reasonably deliver.
🎸Have one of these? Get a price estimate based on its specific condition and details.Estimate yours →Individual Listings (Used Market)
Used-condition sales and current used listings. Brand New listings excluded.
Market Report
Used examples typically trade between $1,525 and $1,675; anything under $1,500 is worth a close look. Prices are down 6.0% vs. 12 months ago. The market is predictable month to month.
Turnover is steady at ~13/month. Supply is consistent enough that patient buyers can find options without rushing.
Condition has a moderate effect on price (~25% spread from clean to worn). Player-grade examples represent reasonable value.
For Sale (20 listings)
Unknown seller • 2024
American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster Electric Guitar 2024 - Butterscotch Blonde
$1,950
Excellent
Curtiss' Guitar Grotto Studio • 2022
2022 Fender American Vintage II '63 Telecaster Surf Green
$1,600
Good
Unknown seller • 2025
2025 Fender American Vintage II 1975 Telecaster Deluxe Electric Guitar w/Case!!!
$2,299
Mint
Pete’s Guitars • 2023
Fender American Vintage II '51 Telecaster 2022 - Present - Butterscotch Blonde
$1,520
Excellent
Unknown seller • 2023
American Vintage II 1963 Telecaster Electric Guitar - 3-tone Sunburst
$2,050
Mint
Brett's Gear Outlet • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '77 Telecaster Custom
$1,378
Excellent
Tyler's Boutique • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '63 Telecaster 2022 - Present - 3-Color Sunburst
$1,567
Very Good
Drew's Gear Emporium • 2025
2025 Fender American Vintage II '51 Telecaster - one owner, two months old, 6lbs 14oz!
$1,899
Excellent
Paolo's Gear Outlet • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '75 Telecaster Deluxe 2022 - Present - 3-Color Sunburst
$2,302
Very Good
Adam Grant's Gear Outlet • 2023
Fender 2023 Fender American Vintage II 1963 Telecaster 2023 - Sunburst Nitro
$1,834
Excellent
John_bsyrett123 • 2023
Fender American vintage II telecaster 1963 2023 - Nitrocellulose
$1,347
Very Good
Grayson's Tune Town • 2026
Fender Limited Edition 75th Anniversary American Vintage II 1951 Nocaster
$3,000
Mint
The Guitar Broker • 2024
Fender Telecaster American Vintage II '51 Blackguard 2024 - As New w/COA, case candy & all paperwork !
$2,495
Mint
Opplemans Trading & Exchange Company • 2025
Fender American Vintage II '51 Telecaster Butterscotch Blonde - 2025
$1,600
Very Good
Daniel 's Gear Depot • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '63 Telecaster 2022 - Present - Surf Green
$1,878
Very Good
Jame's Gears • 2025
Fender Limited-Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster Electric Guitar 2025 - Prototype White
$1,499
Excellent
MUDGE'S MUSIC (at Carter Vintage) • 2025
Fender American Vintage II 1972 Telecaster Thinline 2025, Natural
$2,300
Very Good
JSON's Gear Outlet • 2023
Fender American Vintage II '63 Telecaster 2023 - 3-Color Sunburst
$1,700
Very Good
Tone Shop Guitars • 2023
Used 2023 Fender American Vintage II '72 Telecaster Thinline Lake Placid Blue TSU25826
$1,600
Very Good
Jonathan's Shop • 2022
2022 Fender AVRI II 1951 Telecaster, Blonde, light relic
$1,600
Excellent