Fender American Vintage II Telecaster
Aftermarket Price History
Used-market sales only. Brand New listings excluded.
American Vintage II Telecasters are Fender's current year-specific U.S. reissues, built to go harder on historical accuracy than the broader American Original line did. Era-correct pickups, lacquer finishes, period neck shapes and the right bridge and saddle formulas are what define the segment and justify the price gap over player-focused production Teles. On the used market, originality is everything, and the audience cares more about correctness and completeness than about flashy finish rarity. It is the right page for buyers who want a new Tele that behaves as much like a specific old Tele as Fender can reasonably deliver.
Individual Listings (Used Market)
Used-condition sales and current used listings. Brand New listings excluded.
Market Report
Premium vintage-spec Tele launched in 2022. The $1499–$2250 range is wide — color and condition premiums are real. Unlike some new releases, these appear to be holding value well at $1500–$1800 for typical used examples.
There's a genuine $500 spread between a tired example at $1500 and a pristine one at $2000. Know what you're buying before comparing prices. Still early enough in the product cycle that some price discovery is ongoing at the upper end.
For Sale (20 listings)
Unknown seller • 2023
American Vintage II 1963 Telecaster Electric Guitar - 3-tone Sunburst
$2,060
Mint
Guitars In The Attic • 2022
Fender American Vintage II 1951 Blackguard Telecaster - Butterscotch Blonde
$2,976
Mint
Guitars In The Attic • 2022
Fender American Vintage II 1972 Telecaster Thinline - Natural
$3,083
Mint
Guitars In The Attic • 2023
Fender American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster Left Handed - Butterscotch
$3,159
Mint
Robert's Gear Depot • 2023
Fender American Vintage II 1972 Telecaster Thinline Electric Guitar 2023 - Aged Natural
$1,650
Excellent
FL Tele Gear Outlet • 2035
Fender Fender American Vintage II 1963 Telecaster Rosewood Fingerboard - Surf Green with Hardshell Case 2035 - Surf Green
$1,600
Excellent
Lefty Telecasters • 2025
Fender American Vintage II '51 Telecaster Left-Handed 2025 - Present - Butterscotch Blonde
$2,100
Excellent
Nick’s Gear • 2025
Fender American Vintage II Telecaster Prototype White 2025
$1,999
Excellent
Top 40 Guitars • 2026
2026 Fender American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster w/Tweed Case! Butterscotch Blonde! VERY NICE!!!
$2,399
Mint
The Tyler Roe Collection • 2024
2024 Fender American Vintage II '52 Telecaster Butterscotch Blonde NICE!
$1,896
Excellent
Ricky's Gear Garage • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '72 Telecaster Thinline 2022 - Present - Lake Placid Blue
$1,650
Very Good
Morrell Music Co. • 2024
Fender American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster Electric Guitar Butterscotch Blonde w/ OHSC
$1,620
Mint
Pete's Gear Outlet • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '75 Telecaster Deluxe 2022 - Present - Black
$1,950
Excellent
Grisham’s Gear • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '63 Telecaster 2022 - Present - Crimson Red Transparent
$2,300
Excellent
Gear Bazaar • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '63 Telecaster 2022 - Present Crimson Red Transparent
$1,600
Excellent
Hays Gear Outlet • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '75 Telecaster Deluxe 2022 - Present - Mocha
$2,000
Excellent
Tyler's Boutique • 2025
Fender Limited Edition American Vintage II '51 Telecaster 2025 - Black
$2,100
Very Good
Somerset Guitar Works • 2023
2023 Fender American Vintage II AVRI '75 Reissue Telecaster Deluxe | Present Black w/OHSC +papers
$2,064
Very Good
True Tone Music LTD • 2022
Fender American Vintage II '51 Telecaster 2022 - Present - Butterscotch Blonde
$2,386
Very Good
Point Guitars • 2023
2023 Fender American Vintage II ‘63 Telecaster - 3 Color Sunburst
$1,899
Very Good